Atonement Lutheran Church: A Sanctuary of Faith, Music, and Community
Atonement Lutheran Church: A Sanctuary of Faith, Music, and Community
For nearly four decades, Atonement Lutheran Church stood gracefully at 2040 West 3500 South in Granger—its bold architectural lines and sweeping curves rising like a symbol of hope and harmony along one of the valley’s busiest streets. While the building itself has been gone for almost 40 years, replaced by a strip mall and an auto shop, many still feel its presence as they drive by—seeing, if only in memory, the majestic structure that once inspired awe and devotion.
Established in 1962 by the American Lutheran Church, the congregation’s beginnings were humble, first gathering in Mickey’s Dance Hall before breaking ground on their permanent home. But what followed was more than a building—it was a spiritual and cultural anchor for the community. Designed by architect Charles D. Peterson of Salt Lake City, the modern structure emphasized the chancel and liturgy, with thoughtful design and exceptional acoustics that made every service a sensory experience. From the A-frame’s gentle curve to the welcoming sanctuary, the space lifted eyes upward and hearts heavenward.
Under the guidance of Pastor Joseph A. Luthro, the church was not just a place of Sunday worship—it was a vibrant center for fellowship, music, education, and service. Weekly Bible studies, youth programs, and stewardship campaigns helped members grow in faith and purpose. Sunday School classes served children from age three through high school, taught by a devoted staff of educators and volunteers. The church was alive with voices—children’s choirs, Sunday School pageants, and Christmas Eve worship filled the space with carols and joy. Many remember with fondness singing in the church as part of local school choirs, marveling at the clarity and warmth of the sound in the sanctuary.
The holidays were especially moving. In 1968, Atonement's Christmas worship program, We Sing the Story, united children, choirs, readers, and congregation in a powerful celebration of Christ’s birth. Mrs. Margaret Luthro, the pastor’s wife, served as choir director, guiding voices young and old in songs of faith and rejoicing. On Christmas Eve, children sang Away in a Manger together, while late-night services offered solemn reflection with vocal and instrumental solos.
Weddings held in Atonement’s sanctuary were unforgettable—framed by the soaring roofline and filled with natural light and sacred music, the space added beauty and reverence to every vow spoken there.
Though the building is no longer standing, Atonement Lutheran Church lives on in memory and spirit. It was a house of worship, a cradle of community, and a vessel for voices raised in praise. Its legacy echoes in those who were baptized there, married there, and came together there to celebrate, mourn, learn, and sing.
Even now, as one passes by the unassuming storefronts that replaced it & the busy bustling Pep Boys the image of that grand church lingers—a sacred silhouette etched in the heart of 35th south
